Wednesday, March 30, 2011

The Bush trial will begin the penalty phase on Thursday


Jason Bush with defense counsel Richard Parrish
and Chris Kimminau. 

Convicted double murder Jason Eugene Bush, 36, will soon find out if he was face life in prison or death by lethal injection after he was convicted by a Pima County Superior Court jury of four men and eight women last Friday.

The jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Eligible for death penalty

Then on Friday afternoon it took the jury 15-minutes to find that:
  • The defendant has been convicted of another offense in the United States for which under Arizona law a sentence of life imprisonment or death was imposable.
  • The defendant has been or was previously convicted of a serious offense, whether preparatory or completed. Convictions for serious offenses committed on the same occasion as the homicide, or not committed on the same occasion but consolidated for trial with the homicide, shall be treated as a serious offense under this paragraph.
  • The defendant was an adult at the time the offense was committed or was tried as an adult and the murdered person was under 15 years of age, was an unborn child in the womb at any stage of its development or was 70 years of age or older.

As with the first phase of the trial, the defense presented no evidence or argument during the second phase of the trial.

Penalty phase
During the penalty phase that is scheduled to start at 10:30 a.m. on Thursday before Judge John S. Leonardo the defense will present evidence from two doctors who have evaluated Bush.

Dr. Marc Walter, a neuropsychologist from Phoenix, is expected to testify that the defendant meets the criteria for paranoid schizophrenia.

The second doctor is Dr. B. Robert Crago, clinical director of Neurobehavioral Health Services in Tucson, who performed a quantitative EEG, which is a scientifically established method for evaluating brain function based on brain electrical activity mapping. Crago is expected to testify that his evaluation of Bush produced results that are consistent with schizophrenia and traumatic brain injury.

Defense counsel Richard Parrish provided a preview of the other mitigation evidence anticipated in the third phase while arguing a motion designed to prevent the prosecution from presenting evidence of prior alleged bad acts. “We have not subpoenaed personal witnesses from Idaho, but his natural father and natural mother have guaranteed us that they will come,” he said. “There are other individuals who have known him through his early years that have told us they will come.”

No fallen angel

Parrish said that evidence anticipated during the penalty phase should have no bearing on the guilt or innocence of Bush. “The entire thrust of this has nothing to do with the innocence of this man. It has to do with mental problems that began very early in his life,” he explained. “His father and mother basically disowned him, terminated their parenting of him at the age of 11. His father committed him to a mental institution.”

Parrish also mentioned they may talk about law enforcement contacts his client has had over the years. “We have records of a long series of contacts with law enforcement,” he said. “There are 1,562 pages of documentation about this.”

Parrish also revealed that Bush had invented a fictional life for him self. “There is an entire carton of framed certificates, testimonials from the department of defense, the president of the United States, special forces, photographs of Mr. Bush in a Marine uniform with weapons, jumping out of an airplane an doing various things,” he said. “It is all in the imagination of Mr. Bush. He was never in the service. He created an identity, which he backed up with some astonishingly real looking certificates. There are about 25 of them.”

Parrish made it clear that they were not going to paint their client as an angel. “We are certainly not going to maintain to the court or this jury that peacefulness is the nature of this man,” he said. 

Monday, March 28, 2011

Forde on Death Row

In case you haven't checked it out, here's a link to Shawna Forde's Death Row page at the Arizona Department of Corrections.

A portion of Forde's Death Row page.

Friday, March 25, 2011

Bush found to be eligible for the death penalty


A Pima County Superior Court jury has determined that convicted double murderer Jason Eugene Bush is now eligible to be sentenced to death. The penalty phase of the proceedings will begin on Thursday, March 31, before Judge John S. Leonardo.

Raul and Brisenia Flores
Bush, 36, was also found guilty of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; as well as of one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson urged the jury to determine if the aggravating factors alleged by the prosecution were present during the commission of the murders of Raul and Brisenia Flores. “Not all first-degree murders, standing alone, are something that make someone eligible for the death penalty,” she said. “It’s these aggravating factors that make someone eligible.”
It took the jury 15-minutes to find that:  
  1. The defendant has been convicted of another offense in the United States for which under Arizona law a sentence of life imprisonment or death was imposable.
  2. The defendant has been or was previously convicted of a serious offense, whether preparatory or completed. Convictions for serious offenses committed on the same occasion as the homicide, or not committed on the same occasion but consolidated for trial with the homicide, shall be treated as a serious offense under this paragraph.
  3. The defendant was an adult at the time the offense was committed or was tried as an adult and the murdered person was under 15 years of age, was an unborn child in the womb at any stage of its development or was 70 years of age or older.

As with the first phase of the trial, the defense presented no evidence or argument during the second phase of the trial.

Bush jury finds Bush guilty of all charges


Jason Bush
Pool photo by Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star

A Pima County Superior Court jury of four men and eight women has found Jason Eugene Bush guilty on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca.

Bush, 36, was also found guilty of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; as well as of one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

The jury deliberated for two-and-a-half hours on Thursday without reaching a verdict and for a little over an hour on Friday before returning the guilty verdicts on the charges listed above. Most observers predicted the jury would deliberate for a short period of time before returning their guilty verdicts. The length of the deliberations caught many off guard since the defense had conceded his guilt and asked virtually no questions of witnesses.

Bush displayed no emotion, initially, staring straight ahead. Later, he sat at the defense table with his eyes closed.

The aggravation phase of the trial will begin at 1 p.m. today. If the jury finds the aggravators are proven then Bush will be eligible for the death penalty. 

Thursday, March 24, 2011

Bush jury has gone for the night

The Pima County Superior Court jury hearing the double murder trial of Jason Eugene Bush has retired for the evening after deliberating for approximately two-and-a-half hours. 

The got the case shortly before lunch and began deliberations at 1:30 p.m. They left for the day shortly after 4 p.m. They are scheduled to return to resume deliberations at 10 a.m. tomorrow.

There was one jury question posed during deliberations today regarding the accomplice instruction applying to the six charges Bush faces besides the two counts of first-degree murder. 

Bush case goes to the jury shortly before lunch


The fate of accused double murderer Jason Eugene Bush is in the hands of a Pima County Superior Court jury.

Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Closing arguments

Deputy County Attorney Rick Unklesbay presented the jury of five males and 10 females with closing arguments this morning. The defense, which rested yesterday without calling any witnesses, waived its closing argument in this phase of the trial. “The defendant’s guilt is really beyond any doubt based on the evidence that you’ve heard,” he said. “In the early morning hours of May 30th, he along with Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola made their way into the Flores household and once inside the defendant used his gun to slaughter two people.”

Ultimately, the state is seeking the death penalty for Bush, but that determination needs to be made in phases after the jury has heard all of the relevant evidence in the case. “This is not a time that the jury reflects or decides or deliberates on any potential penalty,” Unklesbay said. “This is the time when you decide whether or not the state has proven to you beyond a reasonable doubt that the defendant killed Raul and Brisenia, tried to kill Gina, was engaged with the others in armed robbery and aggravated robbery as well. This is not a time that you deliberate to decide what should happen to Mr. Bush. This is a time that you decide that the evidence supports the legal instructions that the court is going to give you.”

Should the jury find Bush guilty of the murders of Flores and his daughter the trial would move to the phase where the defendant could become eligible to receive the death penalty. “If and only if you find Mr. Bush guilty then we will proceed on to phase two which is the jury’s determination as to whether or not Mr. Bush is eligible for the death penalty,” Unklesbay counseled the jury.

Confession

Yesterday, the jury was told by lead case Det. Juan Carlos Navarro that Bush had initially claimed that he had not participated in the murders. Bush then changed his story and told Navarro that he committed the murders with motivation from co-defendants Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola who wee pointing weapons at him giving him a choice, their lives or his life. “One thing you are not going to get is an instruction that tells you that there is some justification if a person claims that he was forced to commit murder by the acts of someone else,” Unklesbay said. “In other words, even though he first denied to Det. Navarro having anything to do with the murders, denied that he was armed with a weapon when he eventually admitted shooting Brisenia, Raul and Gina he added the additional element that he only did it because Shawna and Albert were going to shoot him. You’re not going to receive any sort of instruction because it isn’t the law. If someone claims that they were forced to commit murder by someone else because of a threat on their own life and that’s somehow justified it’s not the law.”

Unklesbay argued to the jury that Bush was engaging in damage control when he told Navarro he reluctantly committed the murders. “I suggest that Mr. Bush, when he was talking to Det. Navarro, was simply trying to mitigate his own involvement, make it seem to be somewhat less than what it really was,” he said. “The evidence before you was that Mr. Bush was not only a willing participant in this home invasion and these murders but that he was eager to do so and relished it.”

Brisenia

The jury was also told yesterday by Medical Examiner David Winston that one of the two gunshot wounds to the head suffered by Brisenia had been a contact wound where the muzzle of the gun makes contact with the victim’s skin at the time the trigger is pulled. In his statement to Navarro Bush claimed he was no closer than three feet and closed his eyes before pulling the trigger. “What he did was horrific,” Unklesbay argued. “He wasn’t three feet away from Brisenia when he put that gun to her head. What this man did was take a powerful, .45 cal., semiautomatic handgun and put it to the head of a 9-year-old and pull the trigger, not only once but he did it twice. What he did was horrific and we are asking you to hold him responsible for those murders.”

Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Stonex testifies about his first meeting with Bush


The Pima County Superior Court jury hearing the double murder allegations against Jason Eugene Bush received their first exposure Wednesday to the Minutemen border watch activities.

Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Minutemen

Chuck Stonex
The former New Mexico director for Minutemen American Defense testified for the prosecution. “Minutemen are basically a group of concerned American citizens that are mostly focused on doing their part to slow down or stop or control illegal immigration,” said Chuck Stonex, who first met Forde in October 2008. “We are kind of like the eyes and ears for the Border Patrol. We are not law enforcement, by no means. It’s kind of like a neighborhood watch.”

Stonex had come to Cochise County Memorial Day weekend in 2009. “I was here to attend a barbeque at a friend’s home in Hereford, Ariz.,” he testified. “He’s one of the big players in the Minutemen. Glenn Spencer is his name.” Spencer is the founder of the American Border Patrol.

Stonex said that other than email and phone calls he had no contact with Forde since October 2008. “She was also supposed to go to that barbeque,” he testified.

Gunny

Stonex had testified that he had heard from Forde in those emails and phone calls about someone named “Gunny” in October 2008. Defense attorney Chris Kimminau asked Stonex if he knew for certain if the person referred to as “Gunny” as actually Jason Bush. “It could have been you,” he quipped. “A gunny is an E7 sergeant in the United States Marine Corp. It’s called a gunnery sergeant.”

Kimminau asked Stonex about how Bush told him about his service in the U.S. Army. “Quite well decorated, too,” he commented. “I said if you were in the army why in the hell do you call yourself gunny? He said ‘It just sounds better.’”

Kimminau asked Stonex about a stack of documents Bush had shown to him where he was depicted as an E8 master sergeant in the army. Kimminau asked Stonex if he had seen documentation that Bush had done tours of duty in Bosnia, Somalia, Afghanistan and Iraq. Kimminau asked Stonex if Bush had documentation that he had first aide training, parachute training, marksmanship training and a a silver star award. “Yes,” Stonex answered to each item. “Very authentic.”

Medic
The morning of May 30, Forde called Stonex where he was staying in Tombstone. “She had called me that morning and she told that they had been down around Douglas, Ariz., and had gotten jumped by bandits and that she had a man that was hurt and wanted to know if I had a medical kit,” he recalled.

Stonex agreed to go to Arivaca after attending the barbeque. At that event, Stonex met Laine Lawless for the first time. Lawless asked if she could accompany him to Arivaca as she was anxious to meet Forde.

Stonex and Lawless arrived in Arivaca just after sundown on the evening of May 30. Forde who was driving a teal blue Astro van met them at the Arivaca Mercantile. “He was in the bedroom and had a bandage around his shin,” he testified.

Stonex was not impressed with the bullet wound in Bush’s leg. “It looked like a 10-year-old who had done a crash and burn on first base,” he quipped. “It was very slight, about an inch wide and two inches long.”

Stonex was asked about Bush’s box that contained is military gear. “He had a big old box. I call it a war box. I’ve got one myself,” he said.

War paint

Jason Bush
Pool photo by
Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star
After Stonex had finished treating Bush, conversation turned to the failed operation from the night before. Forde commented that Bush was dressed in camouflage with his face blacked out. “What she said was ‘If you want to see something scary you should seen him in face paint last night,’” he testified. “And, he said that was pretty scary and kind of chuckled about it.”

Deputy County Attorney Rick Unklesbay asked Stonex if he had ever observed any members of the Minutemen use face paint on their border watch operations. “No,” Stonex said. “I’ve seen them out there in bright yellow shirts.”

Stonex saw Forde and Bush at a motel in Tucson on the Monday after the home invasion. “They said it was really hot in Arivaca, there had been all kinds of shooting, there’s been all kinds of stuff and the police are everywhere,” he said.

Stonex testified that Bush showed him various items as they were visiting following treatment for the gunshot wound. “Laine Lawless was spotted a flashlight and ammo clip for a Ruger 10-22 rifle that was broken out,” he testified. “He was talking about how that flashlight, in his terms, saved his ass because it took a hit from a bullet. He said he had it clipped on his vest and the bullet hit it.”
A souvenir
Stonex questioned Bush about whether he was wearing a ballistic plate behind it in the vest. “He said he wasn’t. He had some for his vest, but he didn’t have it in. He said the next time he would make sure to have it in there,” he recalled.

At the meeting in Tucson, Stonex testified that Bush held up a bullet. “He said this is my souvenir from the other night,” he told the jury. “It was a hollow point, .40 cal. bullet.”

Stonex testified he was familiar with that type of ammunition as his personal weapon as a .40 cal. Springfield.

Stonex was asked about when he learned of the fatal home invasion in Arivaca. “The incident in Arivaca at the Flores home was not on the news until Sunday morning,” he said.

As Stonex was leaving the courtroom, he stopped in front of Gina Gonzalez. He shook her had and wished her good luck with the rest of her life.

Love interest

Also testifying Wednesday was Melinda Shelton, who is now using the last name Williams after her divorce. Williams had met Bush at the Grand Canyon Skywalk where she worked as a photographer and he worked as a maintenance technician.

When asked to identify Bush Williams paused for an emotional moment before describing where he was seated and what he was wearing. “I left my ex-husband to be with Jason,” Williams testified.

Williams testified that Bush had moved into her home in January 2009.  She also recounted when Bush was picked up by Forde prior to the home invasion and how he returned two weeks later in the middle of the night only to be arrested by detectives from the sheriff’s department.