Friday, April 1, 2011

Jason Bush’s brother suggests there is more to be learned


Don N. Bush
(Facebook)

The defense in the Pima County Superior Court trial for convicted double-murderer Jason Eugene Bush had anticipated testimiony next Tuesday from the defendant’s father Don Bush.

Based upon comments at the end of testimony on Friday morning it appears the only testimony anticipated next Tuesday will come from Dr. Marc Walter, a neuropsychologist from Phoenix, who is expected to testify that the defendant meets the criteria for paranoid schizophrenia.

On March 25, the jury returned guilty verdicts against Bush, 36, on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

While I may not be able to write about Don Bush Sr. testifying next week I am able to write about Don Bush Jr. courtessy of an email that showed up in my inbox.

“My name is Don Bush, and I am Jason’s older brother,” the email started. “I have been following your blog coverage of the Forde trial, as well as Jason’s, and I have found your’s to have so far been the copy not obviously siphoned from the same pool. And, as such is my reason for having your blog on as home page for both PC and BlackBerry, I have a growing number of irritatingly unanswered questions.”

Bush’s email attempted to pay me a compliment before getting to the point. “As a regular at the courthouse, I’m sure you must be either in the ‘know,’ or simply have a sense of pride and truly enjoy what you do, which is what made your angle stand out,” the email continued. “I would like to talk with you at your earliest convenience, and hear what, if any sort of sense can be made of the jabbing sense of there is a lot more than what has come out, and I don’t follow broadcast media, and am for the most part a hermit, with a once a week journey, to town for groceries and cigarettes, and bare minimum of 50 miles round trip.”

It appears that Bush discovered my Facebook profile which includes a comment about an ongoing job search. “Having also read on your profile that you are ‘open to opportunities,’ and as much as I am as well, I would be interested in the ability to offer to you, any sort of assistance that would afford both of us the most potential for ‘providing the harbor for our ships to come in,’” the email said. “And, if there were to be a dollar finding its way to my wallett, I would want that dollar to be shared with Gina Gonzalez, as I don't know what else I can do to help undo what Jason has ripped away from her.”

Bush did suggest in writing that his brother deserves whatever penalty he receives. “I am in no way trying to soften anything that he has coming to him,” he wrote. “I am just sickened that someone who is born of the same blood, and has just 21months separating him from being a growth on my ass, can do the shit he has done.”

Bush pointed out that the state of Washington may want to try his brother in at least one unsolved murder. “You aint even heard it all yet. Washington state is up to bat next,” he wrote. “You might think about how to be ‘open to the opportunities’ that might be found by a respected, impartial media relations rep from the county where Jason was finally stopped.”

Bush appeared to propose a collaborative arrangement on a book about his younger brother. “We both know I could guide and help locate the persons that would be obscure or seem insignificant enough to not be of real value in a courtroom, but for instance-(little teaser) have you heard of the ‘Aryan Attorney,’ Edgar Steele; who is just heading to trial, for allegedly hiring a ‘hit-man,’ Larry Fairfax, to kill his wife and mother-in-law, and a pipe bomb with no detonater was found under her SUV, at a quickee lube?” the email said. “Now guess who lived on the same private road/driveway as mom, Jason and I? And it was Larry’s house Jason robbed,and stole guns from.”

Bush left thing at that point. “Anyway, I will get off your leg and back to what you were doing. Feel free to contact me any time,” the email said. “I haven’t been sleeping well the most of the last year, so late hours aren’t gonna bother me.”

Bush’s ex-wife and father-in-law add their two cents


The former wife of Jason Eugene Bush told a Pima County Superior Court jury on Friday that she wasn’t fooled by the fantasy military career he had created for himself.
Jason Bush
Pool photo by
Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star 

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts against Bush, 36, on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

Ex-wife

Decolia Cox testified that she had met Bush in 2006 when they both were living in Idaho. “I was working at a convenience store at the time and he was one of the customers,” she said.

Cox has two sons and a daughter from a previous marriage, none with Bush. Cox testified that Bush had always been kind to here children during the period of time they were together. By the time Cox and Bush had married on April 1, 2008, they had moved to her father’s farm on the Brazos River near Waco, Texas.

Cox also testified that Bush had told her that he had once been a master sergeant  in the U.S. Army. “He had told me that,” she said.

Cox testified that she was skeptical of that claim. “I had been married to someone in the military and know kind of what everything looked like, but I never told him that I didn’t believe it,” she added.

Cox testified she had seen the certificates and letters testified to by Melinda (Shelton) Williams on Thursday, but that she thought they were bogus as well. Under cross examination she was asked to amplify her thoughts. “It really didn’t become a major concern for me,” she said.

On direct examination, Cox was asked if she was aware of Bush’s criminal record. “The only time I knew he had been incarcerated was in 1997,” she testified.

Move to Texas

They moved to Texas from Idaho due to the state of her father’s health and the health of Bush who had suffered a blow to the head. “I was taking care of both of them,” she said. “He was hit in the head with an impact wrench.”

The results of the head injury included an estimated dozen seizures and difficulty walking. Cox was asked if Bush might have been faking the seizures. “He was foaming at the mouth and my next door neighbor was a nurse. She had come out to help me get him into the car,” Cox testified. “He seemed to be more disoriented and easily became angry with the situation. He couldn’t walk. He was unable to focus on certain things, just day-to-day activities.”

Cox and Bush separated in August 2008 when he moved to northwest Arizona. There were discussions of reconciliation until she found out from a third party that Bush was living with Williams in Meadview. Cox filed for and was granted a divorce while Bush was lodged at the jail awaiting trial.

Following Cox to the witness stand was her father Daryl Cox. Cox testified about Bush’s health. “I took him to several doctors,” he said. “He had seizures and needed medical attention. He had a seizure one time when we were in the emergency room. He was jerking with his eyes rolled up in his head. He slobbered and was totally out of control.”

Cox was asked about his observations of Bush’s demeanor. “He became angry, quite easily, when his medication was wearing off,” he said. “One time there was some problem with the television. He cut the cord with a pair of scissors while it was plugged in and he threw it through the window of the trailer. Another time he got upset with the kids and he threw the aquarium, with the fish and everything, out the other side of the trailer.”

Bush defense teams plans a motion seeking a mistrial


Prior to the conclusion, next week, of the sentencing phase in the Pima County Superior Court death penalty trial for Jason Eugene Bush, Judge John S. Leonardo will be asked to declare a mistrial in this phase of the proceedings.

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

Mistrial motion?

Testimony on behalf of the defense ended shortly after 11 a.m. Friday when the potential motion was mentioned during a discussion of proposed final instructions for the jury. “My learned co-counsel is going to draft a very sophisticated closing instruction on the issue of victim impact because of the statement that was given by Ms. Gonzalez,” Defense counsel Richard Parrish told Leonardo.

“If you are going to suggest an additional instruction I ask that you get it to the court no later than Monday so that I can deal with it,” Leonardo replied.

Defense counsel Chris Kimminau said he was waiting for a transcript of the victim impact statement read to the jury on Thursday by Gonzalez. “I will be filing a motion for a mistrial no later than Tuesday along with an instruction,” he told Leonardo.

Jason Bush
Pool photo by Dean
Knuth, Arizona Daily Star
No allocution

In this phase of the trial, defendants are provided an opportunity to allocate to the jury regarding the crimes they have been convicted of committing. “Mr. Bush, you understand that you have a right to make a statement as a part of your defense in this matter at this stage,” Leonardo asked the defendant. “Yes sir,” Bush replied.

“Have you had an opportunity to discus that right with your attorneys?” Leonardo asked Bush. “Yes sir,” Bush replied.

“You have decided and agree with them that it’s in your best interests not to do so?” Leonardo asked. “Yes sir,” Bush replied.

Mom testifies

Testifying on behalf of her son, Friday, was Ellen Bower, Bush’s birth mother. Parrish asked Bower about his client’s father and his service in the U.S. Army in Vietnam. Parrish was particularly interested in the claim by Don Bush that he had been exposed to Agent Orange. It was that exposure that Bower feels may have affected her son. “Problems with his demeanor started showing up about 18-months of age,” she testified. “Just running continually into one thing after another and not understanding what no meant. It was a standing joke in our family, it wasn’t a humorous joke, that the terrible twos started at 18-months and he never grew out of it.”

“Lasted into 8, 9 10-years-old?” Parrish asked. “19, 20, 21,” Bower replied. “35, 36, 37,” Parrish asked, rhetorically.

After Bower had been divorced from Don Bush, she testified that her son’s behavior at the age of 10-years-old became an issue. “Jason’s behavior had gotten so out of control. He was lighting fires in a tree house and yelling obscenities at the neighbor ladies,” she testified. “The neighbors were threatening to have him taken away by child protective services.”

At that point, Bush went to live with his father where he continued to get into trouble, this time with the law. “I heard that he had been shooting BB guns at cars and taking mail out of mailboxes,” she testified.

Bower was told by her ex-husband that evaluations of her son had been done. “He was determined to not have a conscious or the ability to tell right from wrong,” she related to the jury.

Bower said she was told that the only way in which her son could receive the treatment he needed was for him to be surrendered to the custody of the state. “Neither he nor I had the means to provide that kind of medical care,” she testified. “I had to legally sign papers that gave them custody of him.”

Admission records

Bush was placed in the Mid-Columbia Mental Health Center in November 1985 at the age of 11 “due to escalating oppositional behavior to his father and teachers at school along with increasing criminal behavior,” Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson read from a report about Bush.

The report continued. “There was no evidence of thought disorder. He was not treated with medications. He was released from Mid-Columbia Mental Health Center and placed at the Crisis Residential Center,” Johnson read.

Bush was placed into a group home in December 1985. “So he spent one month at this mental institution?” Johnson asked Bower. “That’s what it looks like,” Bower replied. “They found there was not mental illness to treat and they put him in the group home,” Johnson asked, rhetorically.

Sexual abuse

About a year after relinquishing her parental rights, Bower heard that her son had been abused in state facilities. “I did get a call from one of the counselors there who told me that Jason had been raped while in the group home,” she said.

Bower was able to secure her son’s release from the state facility allowing him to return to her home at the age of 13. At that point, a male friend of Bower’s took an interest in Bush teaching him welding, horseback riding, water skiing, and blacksmithing. “He traded his own labor to another guy who was a master blacksmith so that Jason could continue his blacksmithing training,” she said.

Bower said her son attended public school for a short time until he got into trouble. “They kicked him off the school bus for misbehaving,” she testified. “He got on his motorbike and put his .410 shotgun across his back and went ripping up the road after the school bus and terrified everybody.”

Following his expulsion from school, his mother home schooled Bush. Then her son was placed into a program dealing with alcohol and drug problems, in essence a reform school.

Is he capable?

Bower was asked if she believed her son was capable of killing 9-year-old Brisenia Flores. “If he managed to do that somehow then there is another monster running around inside of Jason that I have never, ever seen a hint of,” she said. 

Thursday, March 31, 2011

Jason Bush is a paranoid schizophrenic


The Pima County Superior Court jury charged with deciding if convicted double murderer Jason Eugene Bush should spend the rest of his life in prison or be put to death was told, Thursday, that he is a paranoid schizophrenic.

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

Quantitative EEG



Test results for Bush
Dr. B. Robert Crago, clinical director of Neurobehavioral Health Services in Tucson, performed a quantitative EEG, on Bush prior to the start of the trial.

A quantitative EEG is a test which is a scientifically established method for evaluating brain function based on brain electrical activity mapping. “The test is called a quantitative EEG,” Crago testified. “An EEG is a measure of the brain's electrical activity. It's performed by putting some electrodes on the scalp and recording that discharge from the brain.”

Crago takes the data recorded from the EEG and performs an analysis using a computer. He began his explanation with a look at a graphic displaying 19 channels of electrical activity from Bush's brain. “This is what a sample of that data would look like. Each one of those is one second of data,” Crago said, referring to a projection of data in the courtroom. “We took that data and compared it to what we call norms. It is a measure of brain electrical activity that is quantified and compared to an objective database to tell us just how deviant or not so deviant it is.”

Crago told the jury that he was asked to evaluate Bush by another psychologist and by his lawyer. “In Mr. Bush's case I was asked to decide if there was any evidence of abnormalities and if so what would they be consistent with,” he testified. “The impression was, that first of all, this is a very deviant EEG. The test cannot say that he is paranoid schizophrenic. The test can only say deviant.”

Paranoid schizophrenia

Crago suggested that paranoid schizophrenia is different from schizophrenia. “These people are sometimes highly organized. Their thinking rather than being loose and disorganized is actually overly rigid and tight,” he explained. “They're not flexible. They tend to have very black and white views of the world. Paranoids are the ones that tend to get missed in clinical interviews.”

Deputy County Attorney Rick Unklesbay challenged the use of the quantitative EEG as the “gold standard” for determining brain abnormalities. “The reality is that it is the most reliable, the most specific test out there because it is objective,” Crago testified.

Crago admitted that he did not request the data from previous EEG tests given to Bush years ago. Those tests had been interpreted as being “normal” at the time they were administered. “You are comparing an x-ray to an MRI,” Crago suggested. “His brain is not normal. It's sluggish. It's disconnected.”

Bush, the decorated hero who really wasn't


Jason Bush
Pool photo by
Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star

The lead witness for the defense in the penalty phase of the Jason Eugene Bush death penalty case at Pima County Superior Court was the defendant's former love interest and fiance.

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

During the first phase of the trial, Melinda Shelton, now known as Williams due to a divorce, testified about Bush leaving with co-defendant Shawna Forde a few days before the murders and then returning late at night after the murders with a bullet wound in his leg.

Williams was asked to testify regarding numerous letters, certificates and other military documents she had found in her home in the wake of Bush's arrest in connection with this case.

Hail to the chief

Defense counsel Richard Parrish asked Williams to identify a letter purported to be from former President George W. Bush. “This is the Office of the President of the United States, the White House signed by George Bush and is directed to MSgt. Jason Bush,” he said, as he started to read the letter.

“Dear Mr. Bush,
“I am deeply honored to be writing you this letter.
“Your exploits in South America have reached my desk and made for an interesting read.
“I hope that you will be settling down on your upcoming leave as I know that you are weary.
“In addition to the praise of your country, a full presidential pardon for all past offenses will be placed in your service record and a copy will be sent to the U.S. Attorney’s Office for further dissemination.
“My prayers and those of the country are with you. Go with God.
“Yours truly,
“George W. Bush”

One more letter

The was also a letter written by the deputy director from the office of the director of the National Security Agency.
“The director of the National Security Agency would like to send his gratitude and great respect to you for your service to this country.
“Your expedience in the handling of our most recent troubles was an amazing accomplishment and won’t be forgotten by us.
“I know that sometimes a person can take on only so much at one time. You have taken on more than most people could handle.
“We all hope that you will find peace on your upcoming leave. The director once again thanks you for your service to the president and to your country.
“We are all thankful that we have people such as yourself in service.”

Parrish also showed Williams a pictures of Bush and his former wife, Bush in camouflage with other soldiers, Bush holding an M-16 with others standing behind him.

There was a certificate memorializing Bush’s enlistment in the armed forces, a meritorious service award and verification of military experience and training.

MOS?

Parrish also shared a document outlining the MOS (military occupation specialty) identifiers for Bush's make believe military life. They included:
  • Infantryman
  • Explosive ordinance disposal
  • Special forces weapons sergeant
  • Special forces communications sergeant
  • Counterintelligence agent
  • Pathfinder
  • Sniper
  • Polygraph operator
  • Foreign counterintelligence
  • Special forces target interdiction operations
  • Special forces military free fall and underwater operations
  • Counter signals intelligence operation
  • Cryptanalysis
  • Reconnaissance
Notable service?

Notable service by Bush while serving in the military career he invented, included:
  • Argentina interdiction operations
  • Columbia interdiction operations
  • MSRS Antarctica signals and counter signals operations
  • Argentina coastline 44 impact operations
  • Columbia intelligence operations
  • Belize counter signals
  • Panama interdicting operations
  • Ecuador interdicting operations
  • Special Forces Creed plaque
  • Travel vouchers for reimbursement for military travel
Parrish asked Williams if she believe any of the certificates, letters and other items that were introduced into evidence. “Did these certificates help you to reach the belief that Jason Bush had actually accomplished these things?” Parrish asked. “After I found them I didn't think so,” Williams replied. “You found them after he was arrested?” Parrish asked. “Yes,” Williams replied. “I had to clean my house after the police came.”

Upset

Williams testified on cross examination that Bush was concerned about the “military operation” he returned from on June 11, 2009. “He was a little upset about it,” she said.

“Upset about being hurt?” Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson asked. “Yes,” Williams replied. “But, willing to go back.”

Johnson asked Williams about the circumstances that led to Bush losing his job at the Grand Canyon Skywalk. “They did a background check, not at first, but later,” she said. “It was an outstanding warrant, I think.”

Williams testified that Bush had not revealed details regarding his life prior to their meeting on the job Skywalk. She said he had consistently lied to her about problems and issues in his past.

At the same time, Williams testified that Bush appeared to be a normal law-abiding person during their time together.

After Bush was arrested, Williams discovered that he had defrauded her and her grandmother. “I had a bank account with Jason and I also had a bank account with my grandmother,” she testified. “He deposited fraudulent money orders in both accounts.”

Both accounts became overdrawn as a result of the fraudulent money orders. “Now, we are fighting fraud charges on both accounts,” Williams added.

Bush jury has been taught to hate him during the first two phases of the trial


Jason Bush with his counsel, Richard
Parrish and Chris Kimminau. Pool photo
by Dean Knuth, Arizona Daily Star

The Pima County Superior Court jury hearing the sentencing phase of the death penalty trial for Jason Eugene Bush has been taught to hate the defendant.

Defense counsel Richard Parrish told the jury in his opening statement that the lack of a defense presentation should have shown the jury that he and his co-counsel Chris Kimminau were not contesting the guilt of their client. “Mr. Kimminau was very, very careful to avoid during the entire presentation of the state’s case any inference that what was done by Jason Bush was proper and excusable or justified,” he said.

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case. “It was not proper, it was not excusable and it was not justifiable,” Parrish stated. “No one contested for a moment, not one uttered word that this was not a tragic, inexcusable, terrible act and that murder occurred to two people and that he did it.”

Taught to hate

Parrish suggested that the jury was taught to hate his client during the first two phases of the trial. “You were shown photographs of every wound, every bullet that goes into one of the victim’s bodies. You were shown the face of a little girl that is destroyed by bullets,” he said, in a raised voice. “Why? Is it not enough to say that two people, without justification, were murdered? No. You have to be taught to really hate Jason Bush.”

Deputy County Attorney
Kellie Johnson.
Pool photoby Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star
Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson told the jury that the evidence they saw during the first two phases of the trial was designed to prove to them that Bush was guilty of the crimes that he committed. “It was not meant to teach you to hate. It was not meant to prejudice you, but it was meant to teach you what it is that he did,” she said. “What this about is you deciding what is the appropriate punishment.”

Parrish said he is charged with standing before the jury to convince them that hatred is not an appropriate message to be sent. Parrish told the jury they would be shown evidence of the fantasy life that Bush had invented for himself as a military hero.

Parrish said the jury will hear about how Bush’s father may have been exposed to Agent Orange in Vietnam and that it was his parent’s belief that the side effects of that chemical may have been passed along to Bush. “You will hear her tell you that from the age of two on that this kid was incorrigible,” he said.

Abandoned

Parrish said that when his client reached the age of 11 that his parents legally disowned him. “His father put him into a mental institution where he was sexually assault and abused by the older boys,” he said. “While it is true that the acts he committed are incredibly terrible it is also true that from early on in his life everyone literally abandoned him”

Parrish told the jury that Bush had spent a lot of time in jail and prison but had not received any help. “They marched him from psychologist to psychiatrist who didn’t help him because they don’t do that in these institutions,” he said. “Psychologists and psychiatrists in these institutions where kids go and then adults go are there to protect the institution. They don’t have the training to cure. They march him from place to place, from prison to prison, from jail to jail and they bring him here and they say ‘Here you kill him.’”

Appropriate verdicts

Johnson urged the jury to consider the facts and return the appropriate verdicts. “He clearly has the capacity to know that his conduct was wrong and certainly had the ability at any time to say I’m not doing this but chose to do it anyway,” she said. “We will ask you to impose the appropriate penalty and that is death.”

Parrish echoed Johnson’s request that the jury return the appropriate verdicts. “All we want is what you promised use that you would do. You assured us that you could not and would not sentence anyone to death until you had heard all of the mitigating factors,” he said. 

Sentencing phase of the Bush murder trial starts with a statement from Gina Gonzalez

Raul and Brisenia
Flores

The sentencing phase for Jason Eugene Bush in his double murder trial at Pima County Superior Court began this morning with an emotional victim impact statement from the surviving victim in the case, Gina Gonzalez.

Last Friday, the jury returned guilty verdicts on two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca. The jury further found that the murders were premeditated and were also committed while Bush was engaged in other felony activities, including the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery. Following that the jury confirmed that aggravating factors existed which make Bush eligible for the death penalty in this case.

Victim impact

In the sentencing phase of the trial the jury normally hears from any surviving victims as to the impact the crimes have had on them. Prior to testimony, Gonzalez read a statement outlining the impact the murders of her husband and daughter have had on her life. “The murder of my husband and daughter on May 30, 2009, has changed my life forever,” she told the jury. “I went to bed in heaven and woke up in hell.”

Persons claiming they were law enforcement officers searching for escaped fugitives had awakened the Flores family shortly before 1 a.m. “My husband opened the door innocently thinking that every thing would be okay,” Gonzalez said.

Instead, the defendant shot and killed her husband as he stood in the living room of his home. “When Junior was shot I was scared and thought that I was going to die,” Gonzalez said. “My husband asked the defendant what was going on. He stated ‘Don’t take this personal, but this bullet has your name on it.’”

Fear

After Gonzalez had been shot twice and lay on the floor in front of the love seat where her daughter, Brisenia, was sleeping she feared for her life and the life of her daughter. “When my baby was approached she began to answer questions about the whereabouts of her sister. She told him her sister was at her grandma’s house. She was told she would be okay,” Gonzalez recounted for the jury. “I heard her say ‘Please don’t shoot me.’ My daughter was shot at close range like she was worth nothing, close enough to almost blow her face completely off. To think of how scared she was to see a man with his face painted black must have been extremely scary for her.”

Gonzalez told the jury that her daughter was very brave considering the threat to her safety. “She never looked away from the defendant. She looked him right in the eye and begged him not to shoot her,” she said. “The defendant told her that no one would hurt her and that everything would be okay. He lied.”

Gonzalez told the jury about the sorrow she experienced when she had to bury her husband and daughter. “It saddened me to know that her face had to be reconstructed for her funeral. It was hard to see my child in the casket. It was hard to see my husband in the casket,” she said. “It was overwhelming and it still is.”

Why did this happen?

Gonzalez then asked a rhetorical question. “What could a 9-year-old possibly done to deserve getting shot like that? I don’t understand how someone could have that much hate in her heart,” she said.

Gonzalez then shared some memories with the jury. “Brisenia loved the color yellow, loved to draw and her favorite Disney princess was Belle,” she said. “Most of all, she loved changing clothes. She had a morning, afternoon and evening outfit. As you can imagine, laundry was not fun for me.”

Gonzalez said her husband was kind, gentle and he best friend. “Junior and I had been together since he was 15-years-old. We were two-and-a-half months short of being married 13 years,” she said. “We had built our lives together and were looking forward to growing old. He had a great sense of humor, was a great cook and loved his little girls very much.”

Gonzalez said her other daughter still struggles with the reality of the situation. “Alexandra expresses quite often that she misses her father and she has not reached the point to where she is able to talk about her little sister,” she told the jury.

Gonzalez concluded by stating that she has questions that probably will never be answered. “It’s hard for me to understand how this all happened. I have so many questions that will remain unanswered. I just want to know why,” she said.

She pointedly addressed Bush as he sat at the defense table without emotion. “You chose to exchange my husband and daughter’s lives for a souvenir that you bragged about, almost like you had won a medal for what you had done to my family,” she said. “I miss my husband. I miss my daughter. I miss my family. I miss my life. That’s all because of a choice that he made for me.”