Wednesday, March 23, 2011

Letter to the editor from Laine Lawless



Laine Lawless
It's true that Chuck and I have exchanged some harsh words. I have not lied about him at all, but he has lied repeatedly, resorting to ad hominem attacks about my appearance when he can't get anything to stick. You want to know what our trip to Arivaca was really like? Go here:  http://blondeontheborder.com 

It is always interesting when certain people accuse others of doing things they themselves have done! Remember, I was with Chuck that night. I know what happened. Could my account differ from his? Read the book and find out.

As far as the quote: "Two can keep a secret if one is dead." That's from Ben Franklin, and it's a joke among patriots. I just thought Chuck had a problem with diarrhea of the mouth when I sent it to him; little did I know that he had purposely leaked stuff about me to a scummy reporter. I thought it was a mistake, but it wasn't.

The witnesses in these cases are extraordinarily scummy and they lie like rugs. I wouldn't believe any of them.

Why would Stonex care that I am "upset?" So what? I have no desire to do anything to him, other than to use the pen, which is mightier than the sword. He's just mad because he can't do anything about my telling the truth. He makes it his life mission to call every show I'm on for the sole purpose of shouting me down, even if I am not talking about him. He needs to get a life and move on!

I never was subpoenaed for Gaxiola's trial. Stonex has no way of knowing who  was served or for what. Another instance of shooting off his mouth without any  real knowledge. Once the trials are all over, no one will want to talk to Chuck  anymore. And that is the horror that he fears--being unimportant.  LL 

Bush confessed that he shot Brisenia at gunpoint


Jason Bush
Pool photo by Dean Knuth,
Arizona Daily Star
The prosecution rested Wednesday afternoon in the double homicide trial in Pima County Superior Court  for Jason Eugene Bush.

Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the May 30, 2009 deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, at their home in Arivaca, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Confession

 The state called the Pima County Sheriff’s Department homicide detective to the witness stand to testify about a statement Bush had given to him shortly after he was arrested on June 11, 2009, in Meadview near Kingman. “He said that he was the operations director for the Minutemen American Defense, which was run by Shawna Forde,” Det. Juan Carlos Navarro testified.

Navarro testified about the May 30, 2009, home invasion. “He said that he went with Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola,”  he said.

Bush also told Navarro about a scouting mission in the afternoon of May 29, 2009. “He stated that he was taken by a person known to him as Oin in the teal mini van,” he testified. “The purpose was to show Shawna Forde and him the residence that they were going to.”

Navarro said he received two stories from Bush when he interviewed him shortly after his arrest. “He stated that him went to the residence of the victims with Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola but that he remained outside and he later heard shots from inside of the home and didn’t know what had happened,” he testified. “He eventually ended up going to the doorway and that’s when he got shot.”

Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson asked Navarro if Bush maintained that he had never entered the Flores home in the early morning hours of May 30, 2009. “Correct,” he testified.

What really happened

Navarro was asked by Johnson if he pushed Bush using evidentiary leads that had already been developed in the case. Navarro testified that Bush changed his story and admitted going into the Flores home. “He stated that Shawna Forde and him entered the house first,” he testified. “Shawna Forde announced her presence as law enforcement in order for the residents to open the door.”

Navarro testified that Bush admitted they were pretending to be agents of the U.S. Border Patrol.  “He stated that he was armed with a .45 cal. handgun and that Ms. Forde was armed with a .357 revolver,” he testified. A .357 revolver was recovered by detectives outside of the Flores home.

Navarro was asked if Bush told him the source of his handgun. “He stated that he got the .45 cal. handgun from Albert Gaxiola,” he testified. “He stated that when Shawna Forde and him made entry to the home that he shot the father first, the mother second and finally that he had shot the 9-year-old girl.”

No one would be hurt

Navarro testified that Bush told him that it was his understanding that no one at the Flores home would be harmed. “He stated that prior to making entry to the home he was told by Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola that there were not to be any witnesses,” he testified.

Navarro testified that Bush told him that he and Forde had entered the Flores home first because Gaxiola was concerned that he would be recognized. “That was the reason why Shawna Forde and Jason Bush were the persons who announced their presence,” he said. “The homeowner, Raul Flores, would know Albert Gaxiola.”

Bush told Navarro that he was told their mission was to rip off marijuana owned by Raul Flores. “His understanding was that they were going to make entry and rob the residents of their marijuana,” he told the jury. “He said that he went along based on the understanding that they were going to rob marijuana.”


Navarro testified that Bush told him that he had been unwilling to shoot anyone at the Flores home. “He said that he felt threatened by Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola,” he said. “He said that prior to going in that ‘It’s them or you.’ And, prior to shooting the girl he said that they were pointing guns at him.”


Brisenia’s last moments


Brisenia Flores
Navarro was asked to relate what Bush had told him about the shooting of Brisenia Flores. “He said that Brisenia was laying on the sofa and that he was standing approximately three feet away from her  and that he pointed the gun downwards,” he testified. “He doesn’t know how close he got to Brisenia. He doesn’t know where he shot Brisenia, but that he closed his eyes and shot. He stated that Brisenia asked him ‘Is my mommy dead?’ He told her no. He said that he turned around and saw Shawna Forde and Albert Gaxiola and that they appeared to be pointing their guns at him prior to him shooting the little girl.”


Bush drew a diagram for Navarro of the inside of the Flores home and the locations of the victims in the home. Navarro showed the drawing to the jury. As for what was taken from the Flores home. “He said that he knows that they took a box of jewelry and some firearms,” Navarro testified.


Bush told Navarro he was wounded in a firefight with Gina Gonzalez. “He stated that after they left the house Shawna Forde decided to go back in because she thought she forgot her .357 revolver,” he told the jury. “When she entered the home she saw the female victim on the phone and Shawna Forde stepped out and ordered him to go back in and finish her. He said he went back in there and he shot at the victim and the victim shot back and that’s when he got hit.”
Firefight
Navarro testified that Gonzalez was on the phone in the kitchen and that he had reentered the Flores home by himself. “He stated that he was shot once in the leg and that he was hit a second time in his tactical vest,” he told the jury. He stated that after he left the residence he saw Albert Gaxiola go back and shoot from the doorway inside the home with what he thought was the an AK 47. After I told him that we had recovered the AK 47 from inside the home he said then he thought it was the shotgun that he shot.”


As for what happened to the .45 cal. handgun Bush told Navarro that Gaxiola took care of it. “He stated that he gave the firearm to Albert Gaxiola and that he got rid of it,” he testified.


Also testifying Wednesday were Melinda Williams, Bush’s fiancĂ© in Meadview near Kingman and Chuck Stonex, the person who treated Bush’s gunshot wound the night of May 30, 2009. There testimony will be covered in separate posts.


After the state rested its case Wednesday, the defense rested its case without presenting any witnesses or evidence. Closing arguments in the case are set to start at 10:30 a.m. on Thursday. 

Stonex warns that Lawless is upset


Laine Lawless
During the trial for convicted double murderer Shawna Forde I received a couple of emails from an ardent supporter of Forde’s by the name of Laine Lawless.

One email was commenting on the quality of my reporting while the other one asked for my assessment of testimony of one of the witnesses and whether or not Forde’s attorney Eric Larsen had aggressively attempted to question that testimony.

Recently, I have reported on attempts by Lawless to filed complaints with the State Bar of Arizona against Deputy County Attorneys Rick Unklesbay and Kellie Johnson and a complaint against Pima County Superior Court Judge John S. Leonardo filed with the Arizona Commission on Judicial Conduct.

Unsolicited email

This morning, I received an email from another witness in both the Forde case and the ongoing trial for Jason Eugene Bush in connection with the May 30, 2009 deadly home invasion in Arivaca. Former Minutemen American Defense member Chuck Stonex wrote to advise that Lawless had said some uncomplimentary things about me on and Internet radio talk show.

Subject: Laine Lawless
From: Chuck Stonex <cstonex@msn.com>
Date: Wed, 23 Mar 2011 10:38:07 -0600

I was listening to a talk radio show (SOS) with Laine Lawless as the head rattle mouth, and she mentioned that she has a major issue with you. I have a personal with one with her too.

I would like to shut this idiot rattle mouth down. She has slandered me several times.

I am in Tucson and testifying against Jason Bush this morning.

Chuck

“Guns only have two enemies, rust and politicians”

After the trial had recessed for lunch, I spoke with Stonex seeking additional information regarding the allegations he leveled above in connection with a March 3 program. “She had brought your name up that you and her had been conflicting of sorts, that you had been writing things about her that she didn’t like,” he said. “You probably wrote the truth about her and she didn’t like it.”

Stonex suggested that he had clashed verbally on previous occasions with Lawless on similar Internet programs. “This woman is going out of her way to make my life as miserable as possible,” he said. “I’m interested in getting the real truth out there.”

Stonex said he was provided a security escort when he appeared to testify in the Forde trial. “Laine threatened me,” he said. “Laine sent me an email way back at the start of all of this stating ‘Two can keep a secret if one is dead.’”

Stonex said he had provided Det. Juan Carlos Navarro with a copy of that email after his testimony concluded Wednesday morning.

Gaxiola trial

Chuck Stonex
Both Stonex and Lawless are under subpoena to testify in the June 1 trial for co-defendant Albert Gaxiola. “Unfortunately, she’s going to have to testify at Gaxiola’s trial because she was at the house with me,” Stonex revealed. “If you can get her on the stand before me then you can let me counter her. You know damn well that she’s going to lie.”

One of the reasons Lawless was under subpoena is that she could testify to the medical treatment Stonex provided to Bush’s bullet wound on the evening of May 30, 2009. “She still is under subpoena and they’re going to keep her that way and it is for my safety,” he said, explaining that if something were to happen to him that Lawless would be able to testify to the events he has previously testified about.

It’s clear that Stonex is not a big fan of Lawless. “I want to shut this idiot down in the worse way,” he said. “Whatever credibility she has I would like to take it away and just shut her up.”

Tuesday, March 22, 2011

Oakstar testifies regarding plans to eliminate the drug competition


One of the planners of the shootings testified, Tuesday afternoon, to a Pima County Superior Court jury regarding his involvement and the involvement of convicted double murderer Shawna Forde and accused codefendants Jason Eugene Bush and Albert Gaxiola in the deadly, May 30, 2009, home invasion.
Jason Bush
Photo by Dean Knuth
/Arizona Daily Star 

Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Oin Oakstar

During the trial for Forde, longtime Arivaca drug dealer Oin Oakstar had testified about the so-called Arivaca rules. Those rules were that the killing of a rival drug dealer was “business,” but that the rival drug dealer’s wife and children were off-limits. “Women and children are not part of it,” Oakstar testified. “There’s no reason to bring them into it.”

Oakstar testified that he and Gaxiola considered Flores to be a rival in the drug business and they had started talking about eliminating him as competition in late 2008 and early 2009.

Oakstar had testified during the Forde trial that there was no discussion of harming the remainder the of the Flores family. “There was no reason to involve his family,” Oakstar testified. “This was business.”

Defense counsel Chris Kimminau asked Oakstar if he and Gaxiola had been working for an individual known as Eddie who controls drug trafficking in the Arivaca area. Oakstar admitted involvement in the theft of marijuana from Flores prior to the deadly home invasion. “You were concerned that Junior had actually put out a hit on you or would actually kill you?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar answered. “You thought you would take care of him before he took care of you, right?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar answered.

Kimminau asked Oakstar if he was an “old school” drug trafficker where one operation would control an area. “Junior was moving in on you, right?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar answered. “You decided that you were going to kill Junior, right?” Kimminau asked.  “Yes,” Oakstar answered.

Permission

Kimminau asked if Oakstar and Gaxiola had to go to Eddie to obtain his blessing to kill Flores. Oakstar agreed with Kimminau that Gaxiola was more aggressive in the belief that Flores needed to be eliminated. “You wanted to be very careful about the circumstances under which you killed Mr. Flores, right?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar answered. “On the other hand, Albert just wanted to get it done, right?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar answered.
Oin Oakstar taken into custiody.
Photo by Dan Shearer,
Green Valley News

Kimminau asked Oakstar about the way in which Flores handled his drug operation. “Although he was a big drug dealer down in Arivaca he did not keep any drugs at his house, right?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar replied.

Kimminau suggested to Oakstar that Gaxiola was a dangerous individual. “It was not beyond him to kill people?” he asked. “Not at all,” Oakstar replied. “It was not beyond him to threaten people?” Kimminau asked. “He threatened me,” Oakstar replied. “He threatened you with a gun?” Kimminau asked. “Yes,” Oakstar replied. “In other words, if you didn’t do what he told you he was going to kill you and he was going to do it with a gun?” Kimminau asked. “That would be my understanding,” Oakstar replied.

After Oakstar was first introduced to Forde, discussions center on their mutual interests. Oakstar and Gaxiola wanted to eliminate their perceived competition and Forde was looking for a source of funding for her Minutemen American Defense organization. “She said she had somebody she could bring in who would be perfect for the problem,” Oakstar testified.

First meeting

Two or three days prior to the shootings Oakstar met Bush for the first time. “I had been told Jason was a sniper or had been a sniper in the military.”

Oakstar identified Bush as he sat at the defense table in the courtroom as the person who Forde brought to Arivaca to handle their mutual problem. “It seems like he’s lost a lot of weight, grown his hair long and wearing glasses,” he testified.

Oakstar is big in stature himself. “He might be taller than myself,” he said. “How tall are you?” asked Deputy County Attorney Rick Unklesbay. “Six-foot-three,” Oakstar replied.

Oakstar was asked by Gaxiola and Forde to bring painkillers the day after the killings to Gaxiola’s house where Bush was dealing with a gunshot wound. “He told me he had shot Junior, his daughter and his wife,” he testified.

Ahead of schedule

Finally, Unklesbay informed Leonardo that he anticipated the state to rest its case Wednesday afternoon. Kimminau confirmed that the defense has no intention of presenting any witnesses during this phase of the trial. Closing arguments would take place on Thursday morning. Should bush be found guilty of murder then the aggravation phase that would make Bush eligible for the death penalty would take place on Friday. If Bush was found to be eligible for death, the penalty phase could start either Tuesday or Wednesday next week. That phase would not conclude prior to April 5 as two medical experts and Bush’s father are scheduled to testify that day. 

Jury problems in the Bush trial


Raul and
Brisenia Flores

There was a problem, Tuesday, involving one of the Pima County Superior Court jurors hearing the double murder trial for Jason Eugene Bush before Judge John S. Leonardo.

The admonition

A jury comprised of five males and 11 females began hearing testimony in the case this past Friday. At the conclusion of each session of court, Leonardo reminds the jurors with an admonition not to discuss the case with anyone or to listen to any media accounts of the proceedings.

As the trial was recessed or lunch this morning, Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson was handed a note informing her that one member of the jury may not have taken Leonardo’s reminder seriously at the end of trial this past Friday. “Apparently, the anonymous caller was describing something that happened on Friday,” Johnson read from a note. “This anonymous caller overheard heard talking about a case that she was on the jury for and wasn’t exactly sure of the circumstances. The anonymous caller walked by her and the juror told her she was upset for having seen a photograph of a little girl with a gun to her head. That’s what the note says.”

There was testimony on Friday that included pictures of the victims as they were found in their home after the shootings on May 30, 2009. None of the pictures depicted a gun being held to the head of Brisenia Flores, however they did show the wounds to her face where she had been shot twice at close range. “The anonymous caller was aware that the case was being heard in front of you,” Johnson said. “

Juror dismissed

Johnson returned to court with clarification of details from a detective in her office. “It sounds like the juror had a somewhat extensive conversation at work about the trial,” she said, as she handed a copy of an email to Leonardo. The email was marked as an exhibit, but not read aloud. Both sides stipulated to the juror being dismissed from further participation in the case.

Also prior to resuming testimony after lunch, another juror sent a note to Leonardo disclosing something she should have shared during jury selection. Her daughter is an employee at the Arizona Department of Public Safety and her daughter had brought a crime lab technician to her school for a presentation. No action was taken regarding the juror’s status and she remains on the jury hearing the case.

Friday, March 18, 2011

Trial starts for the alleged shooter in the Arivaca double murder case


Deputy County Attorney
Kellie Johnson
(Pool photo by Dean Knuth/
Arizona Daily Star)

Trial started Friday at Pima County Superior Court for the alleged shooter in the May 30, 2009, home invasion in Arivaca that left a father and daughter dead and a mother wounded.

Jason Eugene Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Opening statements

Deputy County Attorney Kellie Johnson provided the jury of five males and 11 females with n outline of the evidence they could expect to her during her opening statement. Defense counsel Chris Kimminau reserved the right to provide an opening statement at the conclusion of the presentation of evidence by the prosecution.

The first witness for the prosecution was 9-1-1 operator Tanya Remsburg who took the called from Gonzalez the night of the shootings. Then the prosecution played the recording of the 9-1-1 call complete with the sound of several shots being fired by Gonzalez when the tall male gunman reentered the house. The defense asked no questions of the witness.

Then the prosecution called Gonzalez to the stand. Johnson asked Gonzalez about where they lived in Arivaca. “We lived on five acres in a doublewide trailer,” she testified.

Gonzalez said she and her husband and daughter had gone to Tucson that day. “We had just gotten back,” she testified. “We had gone to Tucson to get Brisenia some shoes for summer school and to pick up my other daughter at her grandma’s house.”

That daughter, Alexandra, may be alive today because she asked to remain at her grandparent’s house in Sahuarita. “She wanted to stay another night,” Gonzalez testified.
Gonzalez said she went to sleep about 11-11:30 p.m. and Brisenia went to sleep on a love seat in the living room with her puppy. “I had just washed her sheets and clean her room and I didn’t want the dog in there,” she testified.
Flores had gone outside to do a security check when Gonzalez had gone to sleep. “He came inside and started to watch TV,” she testified.
Knock, knock
Gonzalez was awakened shortly before 1 a.m. by her husband, Raul. “My husband wakes me up and says to put some clothes on because law enforcement is knocking at the door,” she testified.

Meanwhile, Flores went into the kitchen and living room to turn on some lights before answering the door. After Gonzalez finished dressing she sat down on the sleeping Brisenia on the love seat.

Gonzalez said her husband answered the door and was told that their neighbors had called to complain that they were harboring fugitives. “They tell him to open the door and that the house is surrounded and they need to take a look,” she testified.

Flores asked the persons at the door for a moment to get dressed. “They said ‘No, you need to open the door right now,’” she testified.

Flores asked to see identification. “They said they didn’t have time to show ID,” Gonzalez added.

Gonzalez testified that a female and a male then entered her home. “He was really tall and he’s carrying a handgun with another gun with duct tape on it,” she told the jury.

Gonzalez was asked about the face of the male. “It was painted black,” she said.

Flores attempted to ask questions of the male and female but received a negative response. “He says don’t take this personal but this bullet has your name on it,” Gonzalez testified.

There was a brief struggle that Flores lost. “He shoots him,” Gonzalez said through tears.

Then, Gonzalez was wounded first in the right shoulder and in the right femur. “That knocked me down on the ground,” she said.

Flores attempted to persuade the shooters to stop. “Junior was yelling ‘stop shooting my wife. Stop shooting her,’” she recalled.

At that point, Gonzalez said two other people came into the house. “I could hear them talking to each other in Spanish. One of them was telling the other one that he has another daughter,” she testified.

About that time Brisenia has started to wake up and the tall male turns his attention to her. “She asked ‘Why did you shoot my dad?’ and he says ‘Everything is going to be okay. Nobody’s going to hurt you,’” Gonzalez told the jury.

Brisenia

The tall male pointed in the direction of Gonzalez on the floor and asked Brisenia if she was her sister. “I could see Brisenia peeking down from the couch at me and she says ‘No, that’s not my sister. That’s my mother,’” Gonzalez recalled.

At that point, the tall male with the blackened face proceeded to reload his weapon as Brisenia watched. “She said ‘Please don’t shoot me,’” Gonzalez testified. “He shoots her twice.”

 Gonzalez also testified about calling 9-1-1 and finding her husband’s handgun in the kitchen and using it to would the tall male when he reentered the house to finish her off.

The defense asked no questions of Gonzalez and they asked no questions of Border Patrol Agent Don Williams who was one of the first representatives of law enforcement to reach the scene of the shootings.

Testimony in the case is scheduled to resume Tuesday at 10:30 a.m.

No ruling from the court regarding evidence of prior bad acts by Bush


The Pima County Superior Court jury hearing the double-murder trial of Jason Eugene Bush may or may not hear evidence that Bush is wanted in connection with a pair of 1997 murders in the state of Washington.

Jason Bush (center) with counsel
Richard Parrish and Chris Kimminau.
(Pool photo by Dean Knuth/
Arizona Daily Star)
Bush, 36, is charged with two counts of first-degree murder in the deaths of Raul “Junior” Flores and his daughter, Brisenia, 9, as well as one count of the attempted first-degree murder of Gina Marie Gonzalez; one count of burglary in the first-degree; one count of aggravated assault, serious physical injury; one count of aggravated assault, deadly weapon/dangerous instrument; one count of armed robbery; and one count of aggravated armed robbery.

Co-defendant Shawna Forde was recently convicted of all of these charges and was sentenced to death by a superior court jury.

Motion in limine

The a motion filed with the court earlier this week defense counsel Richard Parrish wrote that he and co-counsel Chris Kimminau do not plan to actively defend their client during the first phase of the potentially three-phase trial. “He has no guilt phase defense to these charges,” Parrish wrote in his motion. “Not only is the evidence overwhelming, but he was wounded in the leg in the home invasion, and he was arrested in a hospital in Kingman while being treated for the leg wound.”

The motion goes on to state: “He confessed to these murders. The defense in this case will not contest his guilt, believing that if they did so, both defense attorneys would entirely lose their credibility before the jury, which must then be engaged in a defense effort to mitigate the penalty imposed on Bush.”

The alleged prior bad acts in question are the murders of Hector Lopez and Jon Bumstead in state of Washington during 1997. The day after Bush was arrested in connection with the May 30, 2009, home invasion in Arivaca he was indicted in Washington on the Lopez murder, but he has never been indicted for the murder of Bumstead. “The introduction by the state of any evidence of the other murders will simply turn this case into the trial of a serial killer who has never had the opportunity to defend against allegations arising from murders which occurred 14 years ago,” the motion stated. “To do so would be breathtakingly prejudicial and distracting to the jury.”

Clarifications sought

In an attempt to resolve the issues raised by the motion, Judge John S. Leonardo asked the attorneys for argument regarding its merits. “What I need to know in order to rule on this motion what mitigation will be offered by the defense,” Leonardo said.

Parrish told Leonardo that he had faxed to the court a one-page description of the mitigation evidence the defense anticipated introducing during the penalty phase of the trial. “That will define what’s relevant I terms of rebuttal and what is not,” Parrish told the court. “It’s very broad. It’s subsection G of ARS 13-751 which talks about character, background and other aspects of the defendant’s life.”

Parrish admitted that they really don’t know who all of their witnesses will be during the penalty phase. “We have not subpoenaed personal witnesses from Idaho, but his natural father and natural mother have guaranteed us that they will come,” he said. “There are other individuals who have known him through his early years that have told us they will come.”

Quick trial

Parrish assured Leonardo that evidence anticipated during the penalty phase should have no bearing on the guilt or innocence of Bush. “The entire thrust of this has nothing to do with the innocence of this man. It has to do with mental problems that began very early in his life,” he explained. “His father and mother basically disowned him, terminated their parenting of him at the age of 11. His father committed him to a mental institution.”

Parrish also mentioned they may talk about law enforcement contacts his client has had over the years. “We have records of a long series of contacts with law enforcement,” he said. “There are 1,562 pages of documentation about this.”

Parrish also revealed that Bush had invented a fictional life for him self. “There is an entire carton of framed certificates, testimonials from the department of defense, the president of the United States, special forces, photographs of Mr. Bush in a Marine uniform with weapons, jumping out of an airplane an doing various things,” he said. “It is all in the imagination of Mr. Bush. He was never in the service. He created an identity, which he backed up with some astonishingly real looking certificates. There are about 25 of them.”

Leonardo attempted to sum up the defense case during the penalty phase. “The thrust of all that will be to establish a deficiency on the defendant’s part to appreciate the unlawfulness of his conduct?” Leonardo asked. “That being the case would the state still believe that it has a right to present this evidence as to the allegations that the defendant committed two other murder in the state of Washington?”

Unklesbay pointed out that defense experts refer to an incident in 2007 when a hammer fell on Bush’s head at a construction site. “The murders in Washington took place in 1997,” he pointed out. “It’s relevant that the incidents in Washington show that he had this kind of behavior long before.”

Confession

Unklesbay also pointed out that the defense has indicated they may wish to play the entire statement by the defendant where he offers a confession. “Within that statement, Mr. Bush indicates after he admits to shooting Brisenia and Raul that he has never done anything like this before in his past,” he said. “That’s not true.”

Leonardo appeared to decide that both sides where aware of the limits they face regarding evidence in the penalty phase. “One of my primary objectives here is to make certain that both sides understand where they are trying to go with this,” the judge said.

Parrish told the court that they were not going to paint their client as an angel. “We are certainly not going to maintain to the court or this jury that peacefulness is the nature of this man,” he said. “For better or for worse, your honor, there are two attorneys representing Mr. Bush. The attorney to my left is representing him on guilt or innocence. I am representing him on mitigation issues. I have never said to anyone that I will play the statement. My co-counsel may have launched that missile to the prosecution for whatever reason. That portion of the tape is not going to be played.”

Leonardo said he would defer ruling on the motion at this time. “It is the court’s belief that the state’s ability to rebut is limited to what’s relevant to the mitigation that is actually offered,” he said. “We won’t know that until it actually happens, but I think this discussion has made it fairly clear to everyone.”

Parrish added that the evidence the state has collected regarding the Washington incidents would be very prejudicial to his client. “I have never seen anything more calculated to prejudice this individual. The guilt phase is going to end very rapidly, I believe,” he said.

“Absent the defense making it relevant somehow we’re not going to be talking about the Washington incidents unless the court believes it is relevant,” said Unklesbay.

“We’re not stupid enough to make it relevant,” Parrish responded.

“The court won’t rule at this time,” Leonardo said.